Dear MSNBC,

Stop showing that chart documenting the DJIA from election day through today.

For the last 24 hours I’ve seen the same graphic used on Morning Joe, Hardball and this morning with Alex Witt. It’s actually more dishonest than continuing to have the spazzy white guys from CNBC on your air — you know, the spazzy white guys who totally got the financial collapse wrong. You think maybe this says something about their credibility? Just throwing that out there.

The DJIA has been falling precipitously since September, 2007 — five months before the Iowa caucus. To that point, I call your attention to another graph here showing George W. Bush’s huge share of the Dow collapse in relation to President Obama’s comparatively small share. Additionally, President Obama can’t be held responsible for anything that occurred during the transition.

I don’t know what you’re trying to prove or what audience you’re courting, but cut the crap. This graph thing is transparently ridiculous.

Stop it!

Bob

This entry was posted in The Media and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • http://cousinavi.wordpress.com cousinavi

    Dear Bob:I am concerned. You seem to be asking the media to present accurate information. I’m not sure what has brought you so low, but the desperation, frustration, and “Great gollywogs you’re losing it, son” inherent in such a demand is obvious.I believe the best advice can be found in classic children’s stories – fairy tales…especially the original European versions (not the cleaned up American ones)…in which the good and kind are commonly abandoned in the forest, fed poisoned apples, imprisoned in towers and left to the devices of a frustrated troll, or forced to seek shelter with relatives else the wolf huff and puff and chomp up their bacon.The thing about all those stories is perseverance. Only in rare cases does help come, and the evil bastards never change their ways. It is only by remaining calm and sticking it out to the end that you have any hope of emerging from this long, dark tunnel with anything remotely like your sanity intact (although, for that, it may already be too late).In any case, pleading with Rumplestilskin, or Wolf Blitzer (you didn’t think that huffing and puffing was a coincidence, did you?), is not gonna get you anywhere.Grab your little red cape, a bag of bread crumbs and try to hang in there. Oh…and while you’re out in the forest, keep your eyes open for the mushroom patch. Find that, and you will at least get to spend a few hours at the gingerbread house.

  • 24hourjack

    speaking of super disingenuous bullshit controversies…i was wondering how long until it became an issue again but for three days in a row now fox has had at least one segment about pres.obama’s teleprompter.is it a crutch?mike huckabee just said “hes a good speaker and a good reader but not a good communicator”.yeah,i would much rather have a president who cant read,speak or communicate.

  • http://cousinavi.wordpress.com cousinavi

    @ 24hourjackIt’s amazing, ain’t it? You would think the kids would be pleased to no longer have to parse the invented wharrgarbl that spilled from Dubya’s yammering trap.Here’s a president who doesn’t stutter and misunderpronounciate, y’know…words and stuff like words…They can’t even bring themselves to simply say, “Yeah…the motherfucker can SPEAK.” It’s like watching Jack Nicholson think. He could order a peanut butter and jelly sandwich, and a fair number of folks would add it the shuffle list on their iPod.What’s really sad about it is this: It’s the Rove strategy, still. Take your opponent’s strength and attack it…make it his weakness.They haven’t been able to locate a weakness. SOB is smart, good looking, highly educated, competent, no mistresses, not gay, not a boozer, plays hoops, beautiful family, doesn’t shoplift…it’s the sort of thing to drive a Rovian nuts.And so, they ask themselves…what’s he really GOOD at?Seems to speak really very well.And so they send ‘Dinosaurs lived with humans’ Huckabee out to try and float the stunned southern preacher idiot argument that without a teleprompter…without the written word to read, Obama’s abilities are suspect and he lacks real content.Dinosaurs and humans – lived together.The world is 6000 years old, and Obama is, really, a poor speaker………….crickets.

  • http://www.intoxination.net Jamie

    DJIA when Bush took office: 10781DJIA when Bush left office: 7949Why doesn’t the media publish that graph?

  • SillyRatfacedGit

    The media does not care at all about facts. The media is the propaganda ministry (Ministry of Information, of course) for the corporatist/fascist extremists that control this country. Tweety is a tool. Alix Witt is a merkin.

  • http://www.broadwaycarl.blogspot.com Broadway Carl

    …without the written word to read, Obama’s abilities are suspect and he lacks real content.

    Someone mught also point out that he writes most (if not all) of his speeches.

  • http://www.broadwaycarl.blogspot.com Broadway Carl

    *might* Rough night last night.Also, regarding your graph as compared the MSNBC crap, I took the liberty of “tweeting” Scarborough about it.

    broadwaycarl@JoeNBC Watching your show et al showing the DOW tanking since Obama took office. Do yourself a favor and take a look at a graph since 9/079:41 AM Mar 6th from web

    broadwaycarl@JoeNBC The market has been in a nose dive for 18 months. Are you expecting SuperObama to stop it in six weeks or are you just blaming him?9:43 AM Mar 6th from web

    JoeNBC@broadwaycarl We will tell the graphics dept that if they run the chart again, to either do it since 9/08 or 1/09. That seems fair.

    That seems fair? I said September of 2007. September 2008 is a bit better even though it’s hiding the 14000 DJIA peak during Bush’s term, but January 2009 is completely useless.

  • Likala

    “” they send ‘Dinosaurs lived with humans’ Huckabee out to try and float the stunned southern preacher idiot argument”"and what about his son the animal torturer/killer.these hypocrits make me ill!!

  • sjw1977

    With the socialist ideals of the current congress and administration, the DOW will see 1800. Mark it. Second, take a look at the DOW since the democrats took control of congress. Down, Down, Down. Remember the President can not spend one penny without the congress approving it. We should stop thinking the President can fix it and look at congress. There is no hope.

  • JR

    I think the main points about this are:Obviously the stock market slide started before Obama took office. But the investors were looking to the new administration to offer their plans to help fix the mess. When they didn’t see anything they liked, the market started to decline at an increased rate since Obama took office.The market thinks little of the “stimulus plan”, as can be seen by the slide in the dow. To date, there has been very little that has come from Geitner, nor the White House, so the investors are “shorting” (not investing) in the market. Everyone is looking, waiting, hoping for something that will address the core problems. So far not much. This administration needs to come up with something, or the slide will continue. Millions of average Americans are suffering because of this; it will hurt everybody poor and rich and middle class alike.