The Poor Bastard Tax

Max Baucus’ Finance Committee has come up with perhaps the worst idea of the entire healthcare reform debate. Yes, worse than Kent Conrad’s stupid and ineffectual co-op thing.

According to Ezra Klein, it’s called a “free rider” tax. In short, if you own a company with more than 50 employees, you have to pay the subsidy costs for your lowest income workers.

Can you guess the effect of this?

That’s right. Businesses will be incentivised to not hire low income workers. So the workers who need employment the most won’t be hired as often because of this ridiculous “free rider” tax. Additionally, as Ezra observes, guess who would be first to be fired when cutbacks are needed. The lowest income workers. And most despicably:

It could also subtly work against hiring minority workers, because they are more likely to come from low-income families, and disabled workers, because they are more likely to need health insurance and subsidies.

Now, I don’t know if Baucus is necessarily responsible for this craptastical idea. It’s just so remarkably dumb — it has to be a product of Grasshole’s melting brain.

This entry was posted in Healthcare and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • eve

    they are too out of touchthis is also sure to inflame the small business owners to hate the whole health care reform plan

  • tikihoodoo

    When I first saw your remark that Baucus had come up with the worst idea of the whole debate, I initially felt some doubt. After all, the debate has been characterized by some spectacularly dreadful ideas. But you may well be right. This is really awful.

  • http://politicalpartypooper.wordpress.com/ Political Party Pooper

    Bob,From one perspective, it looks awful. From the other, a smart business owner would jack up his lower employees’ salary so he didn’t have to pay the subsidy cost. You could view this as a means of determining medium sized small business minimum wage, and effectively jack that wage up way beyond the current minimum wage.As a business owner, if i could avoid paying a tax subsidy to the government by paying my employees more, I would. I know of few businesses who wouldn’t.