‘What Are You Gonna Do?’

Here’s the healthcare section of President Obama’s speech to the AFL-CIO today:

He point-blank calls the Republican arguments “lies” and asks, “I’ve got a questions for all of those folks… What are you gonna do? What’s your answer? What’s your solution? And you know what? They don’t have one!”

Full text after the jump…

Hello Cincinnati. Hello Ohio. I can’t think of a better place to be on Labor Day than at America’s biggest Labor Day picnic-with the workers and families of the Cincinnati AFL-CIO.First, give a big round of applause to Charlie. Charlie reminds us that in these tough times, America’s working men and women are ready to roll up their sleeves and get back to work.I want to salute your AFL-CIO local leaders: Executive Secretary-Treasurer Doug Sizemore, President Joe Zimmer and state President Joe Rugola (roo-GO-la). And your outstanding nationalleaders: a man who we thank for devoting his life to working Americans-President John Sweeney. And the man who will pick up the mantle of leadership-who we need to succeed because a strong labor movement is part of a strong economy.Although Ohio’s terrific Governor Ted Strickland couldn’t be here, we have Lieutenant Governor Lee Fisher, Secretary of State Jennifer Brunner, Attorney General Richard Cordray, Cincinnati Mayor Mark Mallory, and Hamilton County Commission President David Pepper.We’re joined by members of Ohio’s congressional delegation: Congressman Steve Driehaus (DREE-house) and my great friend-who is at the forefront of every fight for Ohio’s working men and women, including the battle for health insurance reform-Senator Sherrod Brown.And I’m proud to be here with a leader who is re-energizing the Department of Labor-and a daughter of union members-Secretary Hilda Solis. And my director of recovery for auto communities and workers-Ed Montgomery.Now, like a lot of Americans, you’re having some fun today. Taking the day off. Spending time with the kids. Enjoying some good music and good food-some famous Cincinnati chili. But today we also pause. To remember. To reflect. To reaffirm.We remember that the rights and benefits we enjoy today were not simply handed out to America’s working men and women. They had to be won.They had to be fought for, by men and women of courage and conviction, from the factory floors of the Industrial Revolution to the shopping aisles of today’s superstores. They stood up and spoke out to demand a fair shake; an honest day’s pay for an honest day’s work. Many risked their lives. Some gave their lives. Some made it a cause of their lives-like Senator Ted Kennedy, who we remember today.So let us never forget: much of what we take for granted-the 40-hour work week, the minimum wage, health insurance, paid leave, pensions, Social Security, Medicare-they all bear the union label. It was the American worker-union men and women-who returned from World War II to make our economy the envy of the world. It was labor that helped build the largest middle class in history. So even if you’re not a union member, every American owes something to America’s labor movement.As we remember this history, let us reflect on its meaning in our own time. Like so many Americans, you work hard and meet your responsibilities. You play by the rules and pay your bills. But in recent years, the American Dream seemed to slip away, because from Washington to Wall Street, too often a different culture prevailed.Wealth was valued over work, selfishness over sacrifice, greed over responsibility, the right to organize undermined rather than strengthened.That’s what we saw. And while it may have worked out well for a few at the top, it sure didn’t work out well for our country. That culture-and the policies that flowed from it-undermined the middle class and helped create the greatest economic crisis of our time.So today, on this Labor Day, we reaffirm our commitment. To rebuild.To live up to the legacy of those who came before us. To combine the enduring values that have served us so well for so long-hard work and responsibility-with new ideas for a new century. To ensure that our great middle class remains the backbone of our economy-not just a vanishing ideal we celebrate at picnics once a year as summer turns to fall.That’s what we’ve been working to do every day since I took office.Now, some people have already forgotten how bad it was just seven months ago. A financial system on the verge of collapse. About 700,000 workers losing their jobs each month. The worst recession of our lifetimes threatening to become another Great Depression.That’s why we took bold, swift action-passing an unprecedented Recovery Act, and doing it without the usual Washington earmarks and pork-barrel spending. And, Ohio, it’s working.We’ve given 95 percent of America’s working families a tax cut-4.5 million families in Ohio, including here in Cincinnati. We’ve cut taxes for small businesses, and made new loans to more than 1,000 small businesses in Ohio so they can grow and hire more workers.We’ve extended unemployment benefits for 12 million Americans, including Charlie and nearly 570,000 Ohio citizens. Across America, we’ve saved the jobs of tens of thousands of state and local workers-including teachers and first responders here in Ohio. We’re rebuilding America’s infrastructure, including the improvements to I-75 in Hamilton County-led by a local Cincinnati contractor-and more than 200 other highway projects across Ohio.And we’re making an historic commitment to innovation-much of it still to come in the months and year ahead: doubling our capacity to generate renewable energy; building a new smart grid to carry electricity from coast to coast; laying down broadband lines and high-speed rail lines; and providing the largest boost in basic research in history.So our Recovery plan is working. The financial system has been saved from collapse. Home sales are up. We’re seeing signs of life in the auto industry. Business investment is starting to stabilize. For the first time in 18 months, we’re seeing growth in manufacturing.On Friday, we learned that the economy lost another 216,000 jobs in August. And whenever Americans are losing jobs-especially so many-that’s simply unacceptable. But for the second straight month, we lost fewer jobs than the month before and it was the fewest jobs lost in a year. So make no mistake. We’re moving in the right direction.Ohio, we’re on the road to recovery.But we’ve still got a long way to go. So we will not rest, we will not let up. Not until workers looking for jobs can find them-good jobs that sustain families and sustain dreams. Not until responsible mortgage-owners can stay in their homes. Not until we have a full economic recovery and all Americans have their shot at the American Dream.But we can’t do that if we go back to that old economy-overleveraged banks, inflated profits and maxed-out credit cards. An economy of bubbles and bursts, where your wages and incomes stagnate while corporate profits soar. So even as we recover from the recession and work to cut the deficit in half, we have to build a new foundation for prosperity in America.An America with a reformed financial regulation system that protects consumers and the entire financial system so we never have a crisis like this again.An America where energy reform creates green jobs that can never be outsourced and that finally frees America from the grip of foreign oil.An America that commits to education-because the countries that out-educate us today will out-compete us tomorrow and the best jobs will go to the best educated-whether they live in Cincinnati or Shanghai. So we’ve got to do a better job educating our sons and daughters.An America that once again invests in the middle class, which is why I’ve created our Task Force on Middle Class Working Families, led by Vice President Joe Biden, to make sure that our policies always benefit you-America’s workers.And today we’re taking another step. I’m naming Ron Bloom to lead our efforts to revitalize the sector that helped build the middle class:American manufacturing. Ron has worked with steelworkers, service employees and management to create new jobs. He’s helped guide my auto task force. And as my new point person on manufacturing, he’ll help us craft the policies that will create the next generation of manufacturing jobs and ensure American competitiveness in the 21st century.And, yes, we’re building an America where health insurance reform delivers more stability and security to every American-the many who have insurance today and the millions who don’t.Now, I’ll have a lot more to say about this Wednesday night, and I don’t want to give it all away. But let me just say this. We’ve been fighting for quality, affordable health care for every American for nearly a century-since Teddy Roosevelt. The Congress and the country have been engaged in a vigorous debate for many months. And debate is good, because we have to get this right. But in every debate there comes a time to decide, a time to act. And Ohio, that time is now.We’ve never been this close. We’ve never had such broad agreement on what needs to be done. And because we’re so close to real reform, the special interests are doing what they always do-trying to scare the American people and preserve the status quo.Visit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about the EconomyBut I’ve got a question for them: What’s your answer? What’s your solution? The truth is, they don’t have one. It’s do nothing. And we know what that future looks like. Insurance companies raking in the profits while discriminating against people because of pre-existing conditions and denying or dropping coverage when you get sick. It means you’re never negotiating about higher wages, because you’re spending all your time just protecting the benefits you already have.It means premiums continuing to skyrocket three times faster than your wages. More families pushed into bankruptcy. More businesses cutting more jobs. More Americans losing their health insurance-14,000 every day. And it means more Americans dying every day just because they don’t have insurance.But that’s not the future I see for America. I see reform where we bring stability and security to folks who have insurance today. Where you never again have to worry about going without coverage-if you lose your job, change your job or get sick. Where there is a cap on your out-of-pocket expenses, so you don’t have to worry that a serious illness will break you and your family. Where you never again have to worry that you or someone you love will be denied coverage because of a pre-existing condition.I see reform where Americans and small businesses that are shut out of health insurance today will be able to purchase coverage at a price they can afford. Where they’ll be able to shop and compare in a new health insurance exchange-a marketplace where competition and choice will continue to hold down cost and help deliver them a better deal. And I continue to believe that a public option within the basket of insurance choices would help improve quality and bring down costs.I see reform where we protect our senior citizens by closing the gaps in their Medicare prescription coverage that costs millions of older Americans thousands of dollars every year out of their own pockets; reforms that will preserve Medicare and put it on a sounder financial footing by cutting waste and fraud and the hundreds of billions of dollars in unwarranted public subsidies to an already profitable insurance industry.I want a health insurance system that works as well for the American people as it does for the insurance industry. They should be free to make a profit. But they also have to be fair. They also have to be accountable.Security and stability for folks who have health insurance. Help for those who don’t-the coverage they need at a price they can afford.Finally bringing costs under control. That’s the reform we need.That’s the reform we’re fighting for. And that’s why it’s time to do what’s right for America’s working families. To put aside the partisanship. To come together as a nation. To pass health insurance reform now-this year.And few have fought harder or longer for health care and America’s workers than you-our brothers and sisters of organized labor. And just as we know that we must adapt to all the changes and challenges of a global economy, we also know this: in good economic times and bad, labor is not part of the problem. Labor is part of the solution.That’s why Secretary Solis has made it a priority at the Labor Department to protect workers-your safety, your benefits, your right to organize and bargain collectively. It’s why some of the first executive orders I issued overturned the previous administration’s attempts to stifle organized labor. It’s why I support the Employee Free Choice Act-to level the playing field so it’s easier for employees who want a union to form a union. Because when labor is strong, America is strong. When we all stand together, we all rise together.And that is why the first piece of legislation I signed into law was the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act-guaranteeing equal pay for equal work.Lilly worked at an Alabama factory. She did her job and did it well.Then, after nearly two decades, she discovered that for years she was paid less than her male colleagues-for doing the very same work. Over the years, she had lost hundreds of thousands of dollars in wages and in pension and Social Security benefits.Lilly could have just moved on. Instead, this Alabama grandmother made a decision-principle was at stake. She stood up and spoke out for what was right-all the way to the Supreme Court, then Congress, and finally the White House, where I signed the law that bears her name.That’s the lesson of this day-that some things are always worth fighting for. Equal pay. Fair wages. Dignity in the workplace. Justice on the job. An economy that works for everyone, because in America there are no second-class citizens. An economy where you can make a living and care for your families. Where you leave your kids something better.Where we live up to our fundamental ideals-those words put on paper some 200 years ago. That we are all created equal; that we all deserve a chance to pursue our happiness and achieve our goals.That is the calling to which we are summoned this Labor Day. That is the cause of my presidency. And that is the commitment we must fulfill to preserve the American Dream for all of America’s working families.God bless you. And God bless the United States of America.

This entry was posted in Healthcare and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • tiadebella

    Outstanding.

  • scribblechic

    Summer play time is over folks. Time to separate the losers from the leaders.Go Prez Go! You Got THIS!

  • veralynn

    Thanks Bob.This should settle the question of whether the President has abandoned us.

  • Stranahan

    Actually, it settles the question of whether pushback works – the unions made it clear that the PO was a line in the sand.That is what is making the difference. The house pushback. The progressive pushback. It’s forcing Obama to make clear statements.Dissent is not disloyalty. Asking our President to keep his promises isn’t defeatist. Real reporting of the White House’s shifting position isn’t doom and gloom.Axelrod’s backtracks shows that progressives speaking up is making a difference.

  • mary from TN

    “This should settle the question of whether the President has abandoned us.”My thoughts exactly. I was wavering in and out about Obama dropping us, the ones who worked hard and defended him during the campaign.This gives me my hope back.Thank you.

  • Gretchen

    Huzzah!!!!!

  • http://www.bobcesca.com Bob_Cesca

    Stranahan wrote:

    Dissent is not disloyalty. Asking our President to keep his promises isn’t defeatist. Real reporting of the White House’s shifting position isn’t doom and gloom.

    You’re being revisionist. What you and others were engaged in was conspiratorial defeatism. Crying “the president sold us out!” and concocting all varieties of theories about why and when the president will abandon progressives isn’t push back. It’s whiny defeatism.As I wrote before, the Progressive Caucus pushed back. The AFL-CIO pushed back. You fell into the “game over” trap.

  • http://www.bobcesca.com Bob_Cesca

    Also, Lee, who was suggesting that pushing back doesn’t work? Certainly not me. I think you’ve got a strawman thing going on here.

  • JDS

    In Renegade Wolffe says Obama asked him regarding interest in the book – if there was no drama–”What happens if we just had a plan and then went out and said, let’s execute it?” And through the book there were examples of how Obama sticks to the game plan.I believe he knew nearly exactly how this whole health care thing would play out and is following the plan they believed would result in reform.I think today was great. I also think anyone in an interview with Republicans should have asked each time,”What’s your solution?”

  • http://twitter.com/Cody_K Cody

    Actually, it settles the question of whether pushback works -That is what is making the difference. The house pushback. The progressive pushback. It’s forcing Obama to make clear statements.Posted by: Stranahan

    Un-fucking-believable.What did I say, Lee? Is this exactly what I said you would do? God damn you’re so predictable.

  • Eric

    I read a comment over at DKos today that I thought, as much as any other speculation out there, had merit:The commenter talked about how a successful community organizer operates.When there is a broad initiative proposed, the organizer states the problem, general goals, and tosses it out to the masses. He does not manage things at all in the initial stage. He lets the citizenry argue it, debate it, wrangle with it.After a while it becomes apparent who, amongst the group, is arguing/negotiating in bad faith. And all through this the organizer does not say ‘boo’. He remains detached, almost aloof, much to the dismay of the proponents of the initiative.Only then, toward the end, does the organizer step up and say – ‘O.K. – this is how it should be’, and begin to actively work toward passing the initiative.That theory (applied of course to Obama and HCR) made as much sense to me (perhaps more) as anything else I’ve heard.

  • JDS

    Eric,I agree. That seems to describe just what has been going on.Some anecdotes in Dreams From My Father follow that pattern exactly.

  • eve

    I was so happy listening to Obama today. I was very pleased with so many things he said. VERY happy he called out the LIES as lies.Good post, Eric.(this is a bit from Sullivan’s London Times column)In his column this week, Andrew remains confident that Obama will get healthcare reform done:Obama has a solid majority and can achieve all this with Democratic votes alone. So why is he in such trouble? Partly it is that this kind of reform rightly stirs scepticism, and Obama has allowed a hapless and divided Congress to take the lead, muddying the message. Partly it is that the hard right is becoming more and more extreme and its fears have eclipsed the hopes of Obama’s supporters. But the most critical part, in my view, is the public understanding that after two massive bank bailouts and a vast stimulus package, with two still-intractable wars, the US cannot afford even the modest 10-year trilliondollar package Obama is proposing. And Obama’s inability to cut spending while the economy is so fragile means he is constrained from offering fiscal reassurance.So, tactically, Obama is on the defensive. Strategically? Again, he is stronger than he now appears. When the health insurance bill is passed and elderly Americans are not rounded up into concentration camps and granny isn’t subjected to euthanasia, and when many uninsured people gain a peace of mind they have never felt before, and people become able to change job without fearing loss of insurance, the Republican scare tactics may come to seem absurd.

  • eve

    It also is an illogical assumption to say that A caused B to happen just because B happened after A.In this case, A being ‘pushback’ and B being Obama’s ‘clear statements’.Letting the WH and Congress know what we want is important. But we don’t necessarily have a cause and effect here. My assumption is that Obama has not wavered on the public option. Today doesn’t prove that either.

  • J

    When the president said, so many people have forgotten where we were 7 mths ago, that struck me as the strongest part. People have forgotten. Somehow, there’s this perception that this should all be so easy, that the pres could be having a cake walk and is just being an asshole.Getting anything done as president is incredibly hard (even for Bush, something that has also been forgotten). It’s especially hard for this president, in these times. The fact that he’s achieved anything, let alone all the things, is practically a miracle. And it hasn’t even been a year!

  • Big_Ben

    Now… THAT’s the Obama I voted for!

  • Terri

    Big_Ben — yes, it is.The one who wants to keep the profit making in health care when he said, “I want a health insurance system that works as well for the American people as it does for the insurance industry.”He wants to keep a system that [predominately] works well for the insurance companies [first].

  • veralynn

    Good god Terri….it’s politics. We can’t get to single payer, there is no way. With the right being the flat out racists and idiots…..there is no fucking way. The ONLY way to get to single payer is through this legislation. The ONLY way we can get there. Why can’t you see this? This is the way it is supposed to work. (excluding the behavior of the right wing nut jobs.) I think the majority of people on this site want single payer. I know I do. But nothing happens this big in less than a year. If you are a teacher, you should know how our republic works. I respect your opinion, I do. You are not respecting mine. The negativity that you and Lee have provided in my life the last few weeks I could have done without. Have a little faith in our system of government. This President is the first one that has gotten young people to take an interest in how our government works. We, as adults, should show them we respect government. There are too many people out there who don’t right now. The right doesn’t think this is important, we do and we should.

  • Rogect8

    Perhaps now no more “the call is coming from inside the house” jive…

  • likala

    I clapped loudly when the president said the public option was still on the table. I was down after all the defeatism and disrespect for him that’s going on on both sides, but the speech today lifted my spirits.How monstrous his job must be with 2 wars, the economy, etc., etc. He’s got shit being flung at him from both sides but smiles that genuine smile and says the right things. Wow.And where were all the single payer screamers back when this whole thing began and it was taken off the table? I don’t think any of us were happy about it at the time but it’s a little late to start screaming now IMO.Healthcare reform has been attempted for about 100 years and we still don’t have it. If President Obama gets it done, how big is that?

  • J

    Likala: good point. Reminds of the uptick in anti Prop 8 activity post election. Certainly there was some before, but not nearly the level we saw after–when it was useless and therefore, risk-less. But it does allow one to stretch one’s arm while patting one’s own back.

  • likala

    I hear ya J, your insight is right on. The two situations are very similar in how the liberals have handled them.

  • DaBomb

    @likala and Cody-I have been right all along. President Obama never waived on the concept of a public option. This is all kabuki to get that last committee to crap out there shitty bill. Which I understand, that they are producing something and it is indeed crap.Thank you Bob for being a positive light in alot of the darkness that has been swarming these blogs, there have only been a few of bloggers who have tried to be positive; Ezra, Booman, Margaret and Helen, Nate Silver, John Cole and yourself.Thank you for being a journalist.And of course the defeatists are going to crow about how their bodice ripping caused the President to CHANGE HIS OPINION. I said that a month ago another blog. He hasn’t changed his opinion, apparently people need to get their hearing checked as well. The President has been saying the same thing since June. JUNE.

  • DaBomb

    @likala and Cody-I have been right all along. President Obama never waived on the concept of a public option. This is all kabuki to get that last committee to crap out there shitty bill. Which I understand, that they are producing something and it is indeed crap.Thank you Bob for being a positive light in alot of the darkness that has been swarming these blogs, there have only been a few of bloggers who have tried to be positive; Ezra, Booman, Margaret and Helen, Nate Silver, John Cole and yourself.Thank you for being a journalist.And of course the defeatists are going to crow about how their bodice ripping caused the President to CHANGE HIS OPINION. I said that a month ago another blog. He hasn’t changed his opinion, apparently people need to get their hearing checked as well. The President has been saying the same thing since June. JUNE.

  • likala

    DaBomb, like my mom used to say, “don’t break your arm patting yourself on the back.” J reminded me of that last night. They will do a lot of that when/if we get the PO.