Papers, Please

The Republican Arizona law in practice:

PHOENIX – A Valley man says he was pulled over Wednesday morning and questioned when he arrived at a weigh station for his commercial vehicle along Val Vista and the 202 freeway.

Abdon, who did not want to use his last name, says he provided several key pieces of information but what he provided apparently was not what was needed.

He tells 3TV, “I don’t think it’s correct, if I have to take my birth certificate with me all the time.” [...]

Abdon was told he did not have enough paperwork on him when he pulled into a weigh station to have his commercial truck checked. He provided his commercial driver’s license and a social security number but ended up handcuffed. [...]

[Abdon's wife] Jackie explains, “I have his social security card as well and mine. He’s legit. It’s the first time it’s ever happened.”

Both were born in the United States and say they are now both infuriated that keeping important documents safely at home is no longer an option.

Here’s a naturally born U.S. citizen who was unjustly (though now “legally”) harassed and shackled based entirely upon his physical appearance.

Following the Civil War and throughout the first half of the 20th Century, African Americans were rounded up in a similar way in the South. They were plucked off the street on perfectly “legal” charges like vagrancy and sold into an underground slave trade, be it literal slavery or slavery through the chain gang prison system of that era.

Vagrancy laws, at that time in the post-Reconstruction South, allowed law enforcement to stop African Americans on the street and ask for papers proving employment. If you didn’t have your papers, you were most likely arrested and “sold” into this neo-slave trade.

While a neo-slavery component already exists in the form of illegal immigrant labor on corporate farms and meat packing plants, we’re essentially seeing a rerun of what happened in the Jim Crow South played out in Arizona with citizens being rounded up based upon their racial characteristics. I suspect it’s only a matter of time before this law evolves into officials getting paid off by corporate agri-businesses to round up and supply cheap labor.

This entry was posted in Republican Party and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • Tbest609

    I don’t think the new law has gone into effect yet. I read that it starts 90 days after the current legislative session ends. Does anyone know if when the law starts?

  • http://cousinavi.wordpress.com cousinavi.wordpress.com

    I hope no one other than PPP was offended by my peppery language in that other thread. It just seemed necessary at the time.In any case, and retraining my intense desire to salt this post with what are, IMO, perfectly appropriate degrading terms, I can’t FORKING WAIT to see what PPP has to say about THIS.Yeah…just a bunch of individuals, all seeking that elusive American Dream.Someone should start selling t-shirts with your birth certificate silk-screened on the front and “DON’T SHOOT!US CITIZEN!”…on the back.

  • http://www.osborneink.com OsborneInk

    Bob, the underground slavery you refer to had a name: “Joe Turner.” He predates Jim Crow.

  • FIONA

    Just waiting for Arizona to come up with an excuse to take away voting rights now.

  • indyfurnace

    This is the blowback felt from decades of misguided, under enforced, over lenient policy.The fact that all these illegals are here, and no one has done anything about it has created a basic acceptance to what is actually illegal, and either way you look at it, for the most part has created a drain on the American safety net system setup for medical, housing, and essential services.Where’s the unions crying out for loss of American Jobs to illegals. Really anyway you look at this, it is going to be ugly.Both parties are in a sort of catch 22 on this one. It will be interesting to see where this one goes.

  • eve

    From what I’m hearing the Arizona legislature has really screwed the whole state with there stupid, unconstitutional bill.The state is already under severe economic stress.Some sheriff’s offices are suggesting they will not enforce the new law because of the strain on their local budgets.There will be high costs paid by Arizonans because of this bill:The cost of court fights. The mayor of Phoenix is planning to sue the state. There will probably be a lot of legal challenges to this bizarre law.The state is already seeing conventions canceled.The state is going to be seeing trade partners pulling back. In 2009, nearly $4.5 billion worth of products were exported from the state to Mexico, which is Arizona’s No. 1 trading partner.Almost one-quarter (22.4 percent) of all manufacturing workers in Arizona depend on exports for their jobs. (2005)”Independent truckers are saying they refuse to transport goods into or out of the state of Arizona.”Tourism from Mexico is a healthy part of the Arizona economy. “Each day, more than 65,000 Mexican residents are in Arizona to work, visit friends and relatives and shop, according to a University of Arizona study sponsored by the Arizona Office of Tourism.”While here, Mexican visitors spend more than $7.35 million daily in Arizona’s stores, restaurants, hotels and other businesses, researchers found.In an opinion piece published Wednesday in the New York Daily News, NY Mayor Bloomberg writes: “What’s at stake here is nothing less than America’s international reputation as the most open and attractive marketplace in the world….”

  • jhw22

    @Tbest609 — you’re correct. It hasn’t gone into effect yet. So either the story is a lie or some cop is so nervous he is reacting too soon.I really fear for the cops in AZ. There are going to be some assholes, some good guys doing their job and some who are so confused and worried about getting sued that we’re going to have a mess. Add the pissed off citizens and problems are going to spiral.I am wondering when we’ll see the first Rodney King-type of incident. :( Jennifer

  • http://nanotyrnns.blogspot.com/ Nanotyrannus

    indyfurnace sez:”This is the blowback felt from decades of misguided, under enforced, over lenient policy.“No, this the blowback felt from decades of packing local and state governments with people completely unqualified for public service. I can get behind the idea that some sort of immigration reform is necessary, but the policy being proposed at the state level in Arizona was obviously written by Sarah Palin’s Short Bus Riders. It’s a law that allows local law enforcement, and wait for it– local law enforcement wannabes, to target brown people. For no other reason than they are brown. The wont be asking Russians, Irishmen, Brits, Danes or Canadians for proof of legal residency or permission to be in the country.This not the fault of Democrats or Republicans not taking on immigration reform. Both sides have kind of fucked up the War on Terror, but you don’t see Colorado sending troops to Syria because Congress wont take the lead on the issue. No, this is the result of there being no requirement to serve in government beyond citizenship and age.If I wanted to go work for NASA, I better know something about rockets, or at least know that space is not “where Jesus lives”. If I wanted to become a state legislator, I don’t have to know anything about anything. I just have to get people to vote for me.

  • nicole473

    I hope no one other than PPP was offended by my peppery language in that other thread. It just seemed necessary at the time

    Sometimes, only peppery language will do. :) I watched the Moyers clip, and the second half of it as well. I was, sad to say, shocked. I knew, of course, about Jim Crow. I had no idea that the South had managed to reinvent slavery after the emancipation, to the degree that they did.And yet, people have the gall to complain about affirmative action. Or are quick to disclaim responsibility when talk of reparations is heard.Arizona is the post-emancipation South waiting to happen. Probably by design.

  • nicole473

    Nanotyrannus said:

    No, this the blowback felt from decades of packing local and state governments with people completely unqualified for public service. I can get behind the idea that some sort of immigration reform is necessary, but the policy being proposed at the state level in Arizona was obviously written by Sarah Palin’s Short Bus Riders. It’s a law that allows local law enforcement, and wait for it– local law enforcement wannabes, to target brown people. For no other reason than they are brown. The wont be asking Russians, Irishmen, Brits, Danes or Canadians for proof of legal residency or permission to be in the country.

    Agree completely.

  • indyinwc

    @ the other indy: I really doubt illegal immigrants are qualifying for union jobs. Good paying jobs are tough enough to get by legal, educated, english speaking and connected workers with references. That being said, people in this country illegally are well aware of their status and really try to stay under the radar. They fear authorities (especially the police), avoid hospitals unless dying, government service buildings, and any contact with those who could threaten them with deportation. They’re hooked up with jobs whose employers won’t ask questions and pay them minimum wage if they’re lucky. The idea that illegal workers are stealing our jobs and living off the welfare system is pure xenophobia. This law will bite Arizona where it hurts, in the pocketbook they’re supposedly trying to protect. The numbers Eve points out above are true.

  • indyfurnace

    I agree nanotyrannus, bad policy being proposed in the past and now. Really I don’t understand how you are not agreeing with what I said,”This is the blowback (current actions) felt from decades of misguided, under enforced, over lenient policy.”Completely agree on lack of experience/incompetence in Government. But that has been going on for years, and ALWAYS will exist. Which only strengthens the argument, “Why the hell do you want to give these guys more power?” It’s sort of wishwashy to think, “All we need is some more competence in government.”Never gonna happen. People that seek these positions for the most part are seeking power. Plain and simple.

  • http://www.intoxination.net IntoxiNation

    This happened 2 days BEFORE the law was even signed.

  • nicole473
  • http://nanotyrnns.blogspot.com/ Nanotyrannus

    I wondered how long it would be before Texas followed suit.It’s just so transparent. This has nothing to do with actually solving any immigration issue. It’s the same as putting National Guard troops at airports any time there’s a terror scare. Completely useless, but, hey! Look at us! We’re doing something about it! We’re protecting you!The Republican Party has spent decades building a base that is now Frankenstein’s monster. They elect their own crazies and enact their own laws based on irrational fear. The village idiots literally now control their village. I think part of the reason the Republicans are so silent on this jackassery is because they don’t know what to do, but they know if they hold a town hall and ask everyone to calm down they’ll be burned at the stake for their blasphemy.I’d love to call this lunacy, but I love the moon too much and honestly think it’s a lot smarter than the kooks walking around right now.

  • http://extremeliberal.wordpress.com/ Jim in Michigan

    Maybe Arizona can secede with Texas, let’s build a big freakin wall around them, let them shoot it out amongst themselves.

  • Irish Girl

    @NanoYou’re right….I live in AZ. The incompetent Repub loons in charge only passed the law to appeal to the xenophobia in their base. The rest of us are rolling our eyes and hollering about just how stupid, expensive and dangerous such a law is. And as usual, we’re not being heard. Sometimes, well most of the time, I hate living here.

  • http://tarackian.deviantart.com/ J M Ashby

    This is what I was saying yesterday, Bob.This is an excuse to lock up and insitutionalize hispanics. Many of today’s prisons are nothing more than 21st century plantations.This is especially true in Texas, and I’d very very very shocked if Texas doesn’t come up with a new similar law soon.Much of the Texas prison system is privately run and even publicly traded on the stockmarket. Its a huge moneymaking scheme. They make everything from icecream to fruit, corn, clothes, and license plates in the prison which are publicly sold at a profit.

  • eve

    As much as I detest Rick Perry, I will be surprised if he and the state legislature passes a bill like Arizona’s.Perry does not want to piss off the Hispanic voters in Texas. Perry and the GOP have been putting a lot of effort into winning Latino voters.Perry will use the Arizona uproar to request more money from the Feds for border security and he will get it. And he will let Arizona be the guinea pig for state’s passing immigration laws.I do thank Arizona for being the bizarre state right now. It’s tiring to have Texas be the star of bizarre.And I agree with Irish girl — lots of the citizens of Arizona and Texas hate this crap the repubs do to try to appease the most extreme of their party.

  • nicole473

    @Jim in Michigan…Now that would be my choice! :)

  • nicole473

    FYI, the GOP meme on this seems to be that if you oppose this bill, and support boycotts, you are a bigot.Big surprise. Not.

  • ec

    Irish Girl, Massachusetts is cold but we have a lot of water for now.Remember, Republicans and the Chicago School believe that we can all costlessly move if we are unhappy.

  • http://nanotyrnns.blogspot.com/ Nanotyrannus

    Seeing as how the Arizona legislature also wants to pass a law requiring presidential candidates to show proof of citizenship, how long are we betting it’ll be before one of these leotards openly suggests that Obama could be stopped in Arizona and asked to present proof of legal residency?One would think they wouldn’t have the balls to do that, and they really don’t have any balls at all. But they are just that stupid.

  • Irish Girl

    @ecYeah, totally “costless”, NOT! Besides financial concerns (I’m way upside down on my house), I share custody of my daughter with my ex who is rooted in AZ until he dies. So, until my daughter goes off to college, I am anchored here to be with her.I wonder what it will take to get AZ Dems excited to go out and vote this November? I know the Hispanic community is now really mobilized….Maybe I should spend my time helping to register as many Hispanic voters here as possible. I speak Spanish so I could help out….Is there anyone else on this board living in AZ and actively working on getting out the vote for November?

  • eve

    I bet the wingnuts would love to do that, Nano. Stop the pres and ask for id. Damn. Fortunately we have the secret service to keep idiots away from him.And if some politician, who could get close to the prez, DID do that the blowback would be huge.

  • eve

    Oh, and while we are kicking out states for having laws we detest, let’s get rid of California for their anti-gay marriage law.Oh, and Illinois and Kansas and Pennsylvania and Ohio and Michigan andhmmm, won’t be many states left if we get rid of ALL the states with bigots within their borders.

  • Mather Z

    First they wanted to smash windows. Then they wanted to ask people for papers. Now they (through their leader, Glenn Beck) want citizens to inform on each other.And they’re calling OTHER people Nazis?

  • kansasdem

    Hispanic chain gangs – coming soon to your locale!

  • http://www.bobcesca.com/blog-archives/2010/03/morning_awesome_859.html Bob_Cesca

    I expanded this post for my Huffington column today. Go look!http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bob-cesca/arizona-immigration-law-c_b_555521.html

  • http://www.windonwater.net QueenTiye

    Bob, I appreciate your point about neo-slavery, but what about actual slavery?Here’s my take on the legal sloping path to slavery (then) and it’s relationship to what’s happening in Arizona NOW.QT

  • http://politicalpartypooper.wordpress.com/ Political Party Pooper

    Cousinavi,Sorry to disappoint you, but I’m completely against this bill…or wait…maybe…doesn’t that?…shouldn’t that please you?Avi, why are you so jealous of me? ;D